“They might never play, but they’d be ready if needed—like being on emergency call” – Matthew Edgar calls for a permanent ‘ninth man’ in Premier League Darts
PDC
The debate over the Premier League Darts lineup flares up every year. This season is no different. Former professional darter and analyst Matthew Edgar looks back at the PDC’s choices halfway through the campaign with a fresh yet critical eye. His conclusion is nuanced: doubts about the selection remain, but the on-stage spectacle makes up for a lot.
ADVERTISEMENT
According to Edgar, it’s difficult to fairly assess the original picks now that the tournament is at the halfway point. The context changes quickly. “It’s a tricky one,” he says in an extended interview with Online Darts. “We’re halfway in now, so you’ve got data to analyse. As time goes on, you forget how you originally felt—that’s why journals and diaries are so useful."
He cites a personal example from his own career: “When I first started playing professional darts, I kept notes. I actually found them recently while moving house, and I thought, 'Wow, I saw things so differently.'"
Those shifting perspectives also play a role in evaluating the Premier League lineup. Players who seemed obvious choices beforehand can be questioned in hindsight — and vice versa.
The debate around Josh Rock
One of the names Edgar mentions explicitly is Josh Rock. The young Northern Irishman was on virtually everyone’s list as one of the eight, but his inclusion now raises questions. “You look at him now and think, 'Should he have been in?'" Edgar explains. “But at the time, he wasn’t even number eight for me—he was around five or six. He was in quite convincingly."
Read also
That, he says, underlines how hard it is to judge decisions in retrospect. Results and form influence the verdict, while the selection is based on a snapshot. The biggest pre-tournament debate, according to Edgar, was over the final, eighth spot in the field. It mainly revolved around Stephen Bunting and Danny Noppert.
ADVERTISEMENT
He offers a unique glimpse into the chaos behind the scenes during the announcement: “I was at the launch, and even close to the announcement, they still hadn’t decided. In fact, the production team had to prepare for both scenarios: “We actually had to pre-record content both ways because the debate was ongoing right up until the last minute.”
A structural problem
What stands out to Edgar this season is the number of occasions when the line-up isn’t complete. Withdrawals mean players reach the semi-finals without throwing a dart, which he believes could be handled better structurally.
His solution: an official 'ninth man.' “I’ve suggested having a ninth player,” he proposes. “You’d pay them a fee to keep Wednesdays and Thursdays free during the Premier League.” That player, Edgar says, must always be ready: “They might never play, but they’d be ready if needed—like being on emergency call.”
He sees only upsides: “Noppert could have had two weeks already, and maybe more. He’d play the same matches as everyone else, just with fewer opportunities overall.”
ADVERTISEMENT
The key question remains: was this the right selection? Edgar doesn’t think there will be consensus anytime soon. “I don’t think you’ll find anyone now who says: yes, these were exactly the right eight players. That’s because of how the tournament has developed.”
“The most entertaining Premier League ever”
Despite all the debate, Edgar is strikingly upbeat about how the competition is unfolding. “It’s the most entertaining Premier League I’ve ever seen.”
That’s unusual, he says, especially at this stage of the tournament: “Normally, by this stage, I’m a bit bored. I’d tune back in around week 13 for the conclusion.”
Read also
ADVERTISEMENT
This year is different. The variety in winners and storylines keeps it compelling. “But this year, we’ve had multiple winners, big players who haven’t won a night yet, and loads of variation.”
He lists a few of those storylines:
- When will Josh Rock get his first win? (achieved last week)
- Can Stephen Bunting silence his critics?
- Can Jonny Clayton sustain his strong form?
- Will Luke Humphries still force his way into the top four?
- When will Gian van Veen finally strike?
And then there’s Luke Littler, of course: “We had the question of when Luke Littler would win a week—and now we’re seeing he can be beaten.”
Looking ahead to the play-offs in London, Edgar also ventures a prediction. Who does he think will reach finals night at The O2 Arena? “I think both Lukes get in,” he says. “I don’t see Humphries missing out—he’s too strong.”
His full prediction:
- Luke Humphries
- Luke Littler
- Jonny Clayton
- Gerwyn Price
ADVERTISEMENT
After eight match nights, Luke Littler currently leads the table, followed by Jonny Clayton, Gerwyn Price, and Michael van Gerwen.
Does the format need an overhaul?
Finally, the debate over the Premier League format comes up. Is the current system, with weekly nights and a heavy workload, still sustainable?
Edgar understands the criticism but immediately adds nuance. “With live sport, things happen,” he says. “I don't think that's kind of in the thought pattern. I mean, in terms of the short-changing.” He compares it to boxing: “You might get a fight that ends in 15 seconds. There are no guarantees in live sport. You can’t expect a fixed outcome."
He believes the real explanation lies elsewhere: in the numbers. “They don’t guess—they’re data-driven. If they’ve kept it, it’s because viewing figures, ticket sales, and fan engagement support it."
ADVERTISEMENT
He also points to the phenomenon of confirmation bias: “There may be people who don’t like the format, but that group is clearly smaller than those who do—or it wouldn’t continue.”
Premier League Darts will always be a topic of debate, especially regarding selection and format. But as Matthew Edgar emphasises, there’s one decisive factor: entertainment. And on that front, this edition scores exceptionally well in his view. So was the selection ‘right’? Maybe not for everyone. But if spectacle is the benchmark, the PDC seems to be doing something right.
Read also

Lucas MichaelDarts Journalist
Lucas Michael is a darts journalist and reporter based in Cambridge, UK, and has been part of the DartsNews team since 2025. He covers professional darts through reports, analysis, round-ups, and live coverage, with a focus on clear context and accurate reporting across the PDC calendar.
A key part of his work is liveblogging major tournaments throughout the year, providing real-time updates, match coverage, and contextual reporting across the professional circuit. He also reports regularly from events on site and has covered the PDC World Darts Championship from the venue, delivering first-hand insight throughout the tournament.
Within the newsroom, Lucas works closely with the editorial team and supports coverage alongside Chief Content Officer Samuel Gill and reporter Kieran Wood.
Lucas holds a BA (Hons) in Sports Journalism. In his work, he places strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating content promptly when new, verified information becomes available.
claps 0visitors 0
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- correct, but hey, it wouldn't be dartsnews without shamelessly misleading clickbait titles like this.colt17-11-2026
- No it wasn't the greatest checkout ever,who writes this stuff? And more importantly,he lost!!!rick6717-11-2026
- His back wasn't against the wall as he had already guaranteed he would top the group at that point, and it's nowhere near the greatest checkout of all time as there was consequently nothing riding on it. Littler made it clear that once he had achieved the requisite three legs he was no longer even taking the game seriously and was simply showing off with a shot he probably hits all the time in exhibtion play (I wouldn't know, I only watch real darts). Don't get me wrong though, it was still impressive.Deduce635817-11-2026
- Why not just donate £5 per ticket from the world championship? It's a worthy cause,I agree,but currently Taylor can't keep his nose out of anything,as he's cogging on. And he's not even bloody playing!!rick6716-11-2026
- Well,I suppose if you don't play the tournaments ,then why should any player qualify? There are players who enter every tournament,and if they don't win it,they carry on, spending money they haven't won,yet certain players seem to think they should qualify. Winners only I thinkrick6714-11-2026
- Everyone knows what a fantastic champion Taylor was,but his performances in the seniors were poor. He wouldn't throw littler off stage,as he'd miss these days!!rick6712-11-2026
- He produced some impressive numbers in that qualifying campaign. I'm excited to see him compete at the World Championship once again, even if it will be difficult to replicate last year's success even with an improved performance, with the draw playing a huge role in determining his fortunes.Deduce635811-11-2026
- I often think about this very question. I think they should revive the format. They could even invite representatives from MODUS Super Series, with four series winners from the past year, and the ADC, with finalists from the Global Championship and perhaps other events. Why not throw in eligible representatives from the JDC and even the soft-tip game too?Deduce635811-11-2026
- So what if littler missed out, he doesnt have to enter everythingant10-11-2026
- Good, absolutely no loss if we never see this dancing goof ever again......no that is not fair. He absolutely cannot and has never been remotely able to dance!richieburnettrocks10-11-2026







