"It cost Van Gerwen last year missing out on the play-offs": Does Premier League Darts need reserve or Challenger return amid Gian van Veen kidney stones withdrawal
PDCMichael van Gerwen only just missed out on the play-offs for the first time in many years last time around in the Premier League Darts. But could it have been different had the system around withdrawals been marginally different.
ADVERTISEMENT
At the moment, a player receives a bye through to the semi-finals if the player in question e.g Gian van Veen or even Michael van Gerwen all of whom have missed weeks this year decides not to play last minute. This hands a 6-0 win over to their opponent and by proxy screws their leg difference too as a result of such a crushing defeat.
In theory, MVG or Van Veen given they've missed weeks due to illness and Van Veen kidney stones could be the ones to suffer again if they don't make the play-offs. Something which technically screwed Van Gerwen over last year and perhaps given that he is not playing in this week's ProTours, Van Veen has been forced to come back earlier than before due to this.
Gerwyn Price called the idea of Challengers 'totally unfair'. An issue has been that since the idea was brought in amid late withdrawals from the line-up in 2019 and while it brought some great moments e.g William O'Connor's walk-on, it still remains a yearly debate as despite it being popular it was also a needs must as opposed to what was perhaps wanted by the tournament.
Read also
Shake-up needed but at what cost?
O'Connor himself spoke last week saying a shake up is needed to the format but is a reserve player who remains on standby in case of these problems and even paid for it ala the ATP/WTA Finals where they have alternates in tennis to replace those injured and they get paid regardless the way to go.
Mark Webster speaking on the Love The Darts Podcast said that it is tricky as it's not an equal playing field if people are brought in for a week or two then taking points away from the main eight but that in reality Van Gerwen missed out last year due to the rules currently on display.
ADVERTISEMENT
But that in his view there isn't a right or wrong answer with caveats across the darting spectrum if they introduce something like that.
"I get the idea, but I just don't know how you do it," he said. "Who you get and obviously the players are going to be of a different level to say Gian [when he pulled out in Dublin]. It's not an equal contest anyway so it's tricky.
Van Gerwen's injury withdrawal last year in theory stopped his play-off charge.
"It happened last year and it's happened a couple of times this year and it could be pivotal come the Play-Offs, so you don't know how it's going to pan out. It cost Van Gerwen last year, missing out on the Play-Offs when he was given a 6-0 defeat because he couldn't make Berlin.
"In an ideal scenario, you want to see all the players play in the opening quarter-finals and if you get a reserve in it does get that player fine-tuned. There's an argument some people say the player would rather play but that's rubbish. They'll take the bye any day of the week in the Premier League and take two points. I don't know what the answer is.
ADVERTISEMENT
"From a crowd point of view, they want to see someone, but the player would think 'I've got that bit of luck, I want to run with it'."
Does it help the fan experience to have a stand-by?
Laura Turner also weighed in on the same podcast and agreed to an extent about it not being perhaps fair and balanced if they do that but also that a fan in the arena which is often Matt Porter's turn of phrase used to defend the format in general wants to see it pan out in full. So is it up to the PDC to give them that full night of entertainment?
"We used to have 'Challengers' and 'Contenders' so when you're playing someone different each week, is it fair? Is it balanced? If that player then beats you and goes on to win the night, does that then transfer into points or do they just play an exhibition-type match?
"From a crowd point of view, they want to see the whole thing pan out, but it's just how you go about it if it's an option the PDC want to consider."
ADVERTISEMENT

Samuel GillChief Content Officer
Samuel Gill is the Chief Content Officer (CCO) of DartsNews.com, a role he has held since 2020. He is responsible for editorial governance across the platform, including setting content standards, overseeing accuracy and consistency, and guiding long-term editorial strategy across professional darts coverage. Since joining, he has contributed more than 10,000 articles and editorial pieces, playing a central role in the development and daily operation of the site.
Based in Leicester, Samuel has extensive experience in darts media and has been closely involved in coverage of the professional darts circuit for several years. Within the UK darts community, he is a recognised figure known for his consistent editorial output and ongoing reporting on major tournaments and developments across the PDC calendar.
In his current role, Samuel works closely with editors and writers to ensure content meets clear journalistic standards, with a focus on source verification, editorial consistency, and timely updates when new, confirmed information becomes available.
claps 0visitors 0
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- correct, but hey, it wouldn't be dartsnews without shamelessly misleading clickbait titles like this.colt17-11-2026
- No it wasn't the greatest checkout ever,who writes this stuff? And more importantly,he lost!!!rick6717-11-2026
- His back wasn't against the wall as he had already guaranteed he would top the group at that point, and it's nowhere near the greatest checkout of all time as there was consequently nothing riding on it. Littler made it clear that once he had achieved the requisite three legs he was no longer even taking the game seriously and was simply showing off with a shot he probably hits all the time in exhibtion play (I wouldn't know, I only watch real darts). Don't get me wrong though, it was still impressive.Deduce635817-11-2026
- Why not just donate £5 per ticket from the world championship? It's a worthy cause,I agree,but currently Taylor can't keep his nose out of anything,as he's cogging on. And he's not even bloody playing!!rick6716-11-2026
- Well,I suppose if you don't play the tournaments ,then why should any player qualify? There are players who enter every tournament,and if they don't win it,they carry on, spending money they haven't won,yet certain players seem to think they should qualify. Winners only I thinkrick6714-11-2026
- Everyone knows what a fantastic champion Taylor was,but his performances in the seniors were poor. He wouldn't throw littler off stage,as he'd miss these days!!rick6712-11-2026
- He produced some impressive numbers in that qualifying campaign. I'm excited to see him compete at the World Championship once again, even if it will be difficult to replicate last year's success even with an improved performance, with the draw playing a huge role in determining his fortunes.Deduce635811-11-2026
- I often think about this very question. I think they should revive the format. They could even invite representatives from MODUS Super Series, with four series winners from the past year, and the ADC, with finalists from the Global Championship and perhaps other events. Why not throw in eligible representatives from the JDC and even the soft-tip game too?Deduce635811-11-2026
- So what if littler missed out, he doesnt have to enter everythingant10-11-2026
- Good, absolutely no loss if we never see this dancing goof ever again......no that is not fair. He absolutely cannot and has never been remotely able to dance!richieburnettrocks10-11-2026





