“I think 99% of people around the world will say no” – Paul Nicholson comments on James Wade’s omission from the Premier League Darts

The omission of James Wade from the Premier League Darts 2026 has sparked considerable debate in the darts world. Wade stated on social media that he was disappointed not to receive an invitation, but according to former professional and current analyst Paul Nicholson, that disappointment is hard to justify. In his analysis, Nicholson argues that Wade simply did not show enough to claim one of the coveted eight spots.

According to Nicholson, the discussion needs proper context. “Premier League Darts isn’t just any tournament,” he emphasises. “It may be the most competitive stage in modern darts.” With only eight places available and a group of at least sixteen players who can realistically claim they deserve inclusion, the bar is extremely high. In that light, Nicholson believes it is fair to scrutinise what Wade has actually achieved.

The Englishman did enjoy a steady spell last season, but the major trophies never arrived. Wade reached multiple finals, yet rarely converted them into tournament wins. Nicholson therefore labels him a “multiple losing finalist” at this stage of his career. “Reaching finals is admirable, but in this era it simply isn’t enough,” the analyst says. “Certainly not when you look at what others have won.”

Nicholson points out that Premier League Darts has changed significantly over the years. Whereas a final at a major televised event like the World Matchplay might have been enough for selection ten years ago, different standards apply today. “The level has risen enormously,” he states. “The depth of the field is greater than ever. What used to be impressive is now often merely average.”

A key stumbling block in assessing Wade, according to Nicholson, is his display at the World Darts Championship. That event remains decisive for reputation, momentum, and status within the PDC. “Once again Wade failed to make a defining impression there,” Nicholson analyses. “And that is precisely the stage where you must set yourself apart if you want to stake a claim for a Premier League spot.”

Nicholson stresses that he understands players are disappointed when overlooked, but believes self-reflection is essential. “I think some of these dart players need to take a long, hard look at themselves in the mirror,” he says. “The question shouldn’t be why someone else was picked, but what you could have done better yourself.”

That Wade believes he had a right to selection is fair enough, according to Nicholson. "If he believes that, fair enough," he said. "But I think 99% of people around the world will say, no, not quite enough this time."

Looking ahead, Nicholson still sees opportunities for Wade. The message is clear: anyone who wants to return to Premier League Darts must deliver on the biggest stages. “If he elevates his game at the Worlds and starts winning major titles again, no one will talk about missed chances,” Nicholson concludes. “But in this generation of darts, mediocrity simply isn’t enough.”