
The PDC has been going for over 30 years now and whilst the majority of major titles have been collected by the usual suspects such as Phil Taylor, Michael van Gerwen, James Wade and Gary Anderson, there have been some tournaments where the winner completely out of the blue.
ADVERTISEMENT
In this article, Dartsnews.com takes a look at the ten most surprising and unsuspected winners of major tournaments in PDC history.
Read also
Larry Butler - 1994 World Matchplay
The first and so far only American to lift a major PDC title, Larry Butler shocked the world in 1994 when he left Blackpool with the inaugural World Matchplay title. Although Butler had shown some signs of his abilities with a win over John Lowe in the World Championship earlier that year, few fancied ‘The Eagle’ heading into the World Matchplay.
Nevertheless, with wins over Steve Raw (8-2), compatriot Jerry Umberger (8-2), Jocky Wilson (11-4) and Shayne Burgess (11-7), Butler found himself facing Dennis Priestley in the final at the Winter Gardens. Averaging 92.7, Butler stunned the first ever PDC world champion 16-12, taking the title and what would turn out to be his biggest career win.

Larry Butler entered the history books as the first winner of the World Matchplay
Read also
Peter Evison - World Matchplay 1996
ADVERTISEMENT
Two years after Butler, the big names were again upset at the Winter Gardens. In the opening round, Evison actually defeated Butler 8-3 before taking a massive win in the second round over the great Phil Taylor. Averaging a touch under 104, Evison switched off ‘The Power’ 8-1 and then avoided the fate that so often befalls those who beat Taylor, by backing it up in the next round with an 11-3 win over American Sean Downs.
In the semifinals, Jamie Harvey also fell to Evison before, in the final, much like when Butler won, Dennis Priestley was left rueing a missed opportunity as Evison prevailed By 16 legs to 14, averaging over 100 again and lifting the title.

The 1996 World Matchplay also had a surprising winner in the name of Peter Evison
Read also
Roland Scholten - UK Open 2004
Already an established name by the time the 2004 UK Open came around, Roland Scholten had been there or thereabouts in the PDC majors for a few seasons, reaching the final of the 2001 World Grand Prix and semifinals at each of the UK Open and Las Vegas Desert Classic. In the era of Phil Taylor's most epic dominance however, the Dutchman was by no means expected to lift the title in Bolton in 2004.
When Phil Taylor struck his second televised nine darter in the fourth round, another title for the Power looked on the cards. Scholten meanwhile was quietly moving his way through the draw. In the quarter-finals, Taylor was dumped out by long time rival John Part in a thriller and after Scholten saw off Alan Warriner the draw was suddenly wide open. After recovering from 3-0 down to beat Steve Beaton 8-4 in the semifinals, Scholten then defeated Part 11-6 in the final to lift the title.
ADVERTISEMENT
Read also
Paul Nicholson - Players Championship Finals 2010
For a short spell, Paul Nicholson looked set to take the darting world by storm. Walking out with his trademark sunglasses and tie, Nicholson was the pantomime villain wmto the crowd but could more than back it up on the board too. At the 2010 Players Championship Finals, Nicholson's looked to have kicked on to the next level. Sadly however, it proved to be the sharp peak of the Asset's career in the PDC.
Whilst Nicholson was an emerging talent at the time, his title win and the route to victory ensure his title win enters our list. Incredibly, his route to the final reads like a who's who of the PDC era. Dennis Priestley fell in the opening round before Steve Beaton and Adrian Lewis followed. In the semi-finals however, Nicholson produced arguably his greatest ever performance to dispatch Phil Taylor 10-9 in an absolute thriller. Surviving another testing encounter in the final with Mervyn King 13-11, Nicholson joined the elite list of PDC major winners.

Paul Nicholson crowned himself the surprise winner of the 2010 Players Championship Finals
ADVERTISEMENT
Read also
Scott Waites - Grand Slam of Darts 2010
Whilst the BDO and PDC had often been at odds since the latter's formation, the Grand Slam of Darts offered darts fans a unique chance to view the two codes best players facing off. In truth, the BDO’s often failed to make much of an impact over the years, that is except for two time Lakeside champion Scott Waites.
Joined by Dave Chisnall, John Henderson, Tony O'Shea, Martyn Phillips, Darryl Fitton and Ted Hankey as the BDO representatives, Waites topped a group that included the aforementioned Phillips, Co Stompe and Adrian Lewis. In the first knockout round, Raymond van Barneveld's hopes were ended 10-7, before Stompe was again beaten by Waites 16-10. In the semifinals, Steve Beaton couldn't handle ‘Scotty 2 Hotty’, with Waites setting up a final showdown with James Wade. Having been obliterated 16-2 by Phil Taylor in the previous year's final, Waites would've been forgiven for giving up hope when trailing Wade 8-0. The Englishman refused to be denied again however and mounted an incredible comeback to seal the title with a 16-12 win becoming the only BDO winner of the Grand Slam.

Scott Waites became the only BDO winner of the Grand Slam of Darts in 2010
Read also
ADVERTISEMENT
Kevin Painter - Players Championship Finals 2011
In the first decade of this century, Kevin Painter was considered one of the top players on the PDC circuit. 'The Artist' regularly made it to the final stages at major finals such as the World Matchplay and World Grand Prix, and even stood in the final of the 2004 World Darts Championship. Painter was very close to the world title then, but eventually lost the final 7-6 to Phil Taylor.
Just when Painter seemed past his prime, that long-hoped-for major title still came. In 2011, he won the Players Championship Finals, making his record a major title after all.
Painter had qualified for the tournament in Doncaster as number 18 on the Players Championship Order of Merit. He began the tournament with a 6-2 victory over Colin Osborne before beating Gary Anderson 8-4. Painter then reached the final match after victories over Mervyn King (9-7) and Scott Rand (10-9). He was then too strong for Mark Webster in the final, 13-9.

ADVERTISEMENT
Mensur Suljovic - Champions League of Darts 2017
From 2015 to 2019, Mensur Suljovic was considered a very tough opponent for all the top players on the PDC circuit. With his unorthodox style of play and headstrong pace, he drove several big names to despair.
In the midst of his heyday, Suljovic managed to win the Champions League of Darts. The BBC tournament then featured eight players, with Phil Taylor, Raymond van Barneveld, Michael van Gerwen, Adrian Lewis, Gary Anderson, Peter Wright and Dave Chisnall in addition to Suljovic.
Suljovic found himself in a pool with Anderson, Wright and Chisnall. He beat them all, as 'The Gentle' started the tournament with a resounding victory over Anderson (10-3). After that he also defeated Wright (10-8) and Chisnall (10-5). In the semifinals, he defeated Raymond van Barneveld (11-9), before Suljovic beat Anderson again (11-9) in the final.

Mensur Suljovic is one of the few players to have won the Champions League of Darts
ADVERTISEMENT
Jose de Sousa - Grand Slam of Darts 2020
At the 2012 World Darts Championship, there was suddenly a Portuguese in the preliminary round of the World Darts Championship. Jose de Sousa failed to win his preliminary round match, then disappeared from the big stage again for several years.
At the 2019 edition, he returned to Alexandra Palace, and then 'The Special One' picked up a Tour Card at the Q-School. That same year, De Sousa already won his first Players Championship title. It turned out to be the prelude to an extraordinary 2020, in which De Sousa won not only a Euro Tour tournament but also a major. The Portuguese darter had never reached the quarterfinals of a major before, but out of nowhere he won the Grand Slam of Darts.
De Sousa lost a group match against Michael Smith (5-2), but advanced to the knockout stage thanks to wins over Krzysztof Ratajski (5-4) and Lisa Ashton (5-1). He then dealt with Dave Chisnall (10-7), Michael Smith (16-14), Simon Whitlock (16-12) and James Wade (16-12) to take the title.

He was already the first Portuguese Players Championship and Euro Tour winner, but also became the first Portuguese major winner at the Grand Slam of Darts in 2020
ADVERTISEMENT
Read also
Ross Smith - European Championship 2022
In October 2022, Ross Smith established his name in the PDC history books as a major winner. 'Smudger' had already reached the quarterfinals at the UK Open once in 2019, but since then never managed to get past the last sixteen of a PDC major. Until the European Championship in 2022.
Smith played only five of 12 Euro Tour tournaments in 2022, but thanks to two quarterfinals he still qualified for the final tournament at the Westfalenhallen in Dortmund.
The Englishman opened the tournament with a 6-4 victory over Joe Cullen, before beating Dimitri van den Bergh (10-8), Peter Wright (10-8) and Chris Dobey (11-9) for a spot in the final. Ross Smith seemed the ideal opponent in the final for Michael Smith, who at that point had already lost seven major finals. However, an eighth defeat was added to that, as after a sensational match, Ross Smith drew the longest straw in the final, 11-8.

Ross Smith decided the Battle of the Smiths in his favor and took the title at the 2022 European Championships
Andrew Gilding - UK Open 2023
At 52, winning your first major by beating top favorite Michael van Gerwen in the final. It sounds like a dream, but Andrew Gilding made that dream come true at the 2023 UK Open.
Gilding began his participation in the 2023 UK Open with wins over Darren Webster (6-2), Ricky Evans (10-5), Luke Woodhouse (10-5) and Brendan Dolan (10-8) to qualify for the final day.
In the quarterfinals, he convincingly dealt with Martin Schindler (10-4), before 'Goldfinger' was too strong for another tournament sensation in the semifinals. An 11-6 win kept Adam Gawlas from a final spot.
Van Gerwen led 9-6 and 10-9 in the final, but missed one matchdart in the deciding leg to win the tournament. Gilding then threw his first matchdart into the double 20 to become the oldest darter in PDC history to win his first major final.

Andrew Gilding became the oldest darter in PDC history to win his first major final

Kieran WoodDarts Journalist
Kieran Wood is a sports journalist based in Wales and has been active in journalism since 2022. He contributes to DartsNews.com, where he covers professional darts through news, match reports, analysis, and live coverage across the PDC calendar and major tournaments.
A key part of his work is on-site reporting from leading events. Kieran has covered the PDC World Darts Championship in person, reporting daily from the venue and providing first-hand insight from the tournament. During his coverage, he has conducted interviews with leading players including Luke Littler, Luke Humphries, and Gerwyn Price.
He is also one of the leading voices of the English-language Dartsnews Podcast, contributing regular analysis and discussion on developments across the professional darts circuit.
In his reporting, Kieran places strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating articles when new, verified information becomes available.
claps 5visitors 3
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- And why should he listen to you?Deduce635807-11-2026
- Ultimately it is a bye for whoever draws Barney. It will be another stroppy and sulky performance once he goes behind. Barney was excellent but really must completely call it a day now.richieburnettrocks07-11-2026
- I'm disappointed he was not able to secure a spot at the Grand Slam. With Carl Sneyd taking care of Daryl Gurney, he would have had to beat Andy Boulton before facing the winner of Sneyd vs Mensur Suljović for a Grand Slam spot. Unfortunately, after beating Filip Bereza comfortably, he succumbed to Boulton, and the board would ultimately be won by the highly inconsistent Carl Sneyd. Since he could instead have been drawn against the likes of Cristo Reyes, Dirk van Duijvenbode and Stephen Bunting, I think once Gurney was out of the picture he would have been favourite to win his board, and it seems like a massive missed opportunity to put 5 grand on his ranking and seal another major TV appearance ahead of the Worlds. The highs and lows of following Raymond van Barneveld!Deduce635806-11-2026
- Probably i will receive a lot of backlash and hate for this reaction, but well, so be it. I am more than sick and tired of those lies of you Barry Hearn. How dare you defend yourself over the back of Fallon’s son! He has a disability and not an illness, so let me correct that for you! I know because I have the exact same disability. I have tried to reach out to Fallon in the past, and offered her to help her and her son, because I was struggling with the same problems, and I understood the boy. I wanted him to have finally someone who understood him. However she told me that she did not want my help, and I have respected Fallon’s choice. I have never asked Fallon for money. They don’t need money in that case. I only ever wanted the best for Fallon and Rory, but I have to be honest about the situation. Fallon should tell the true story and not be forced to tell lies. I don’t hate Fallon, and I don’t begrudge or envy a single penny that she gets, but this situation/case is just not fair. I hate the lies and the dishonesty and injustice. I don’t want Fallon to be hated because there is an unfair disadvantage created. Don’t proclaim your false lies over the back of Rory! I only stand for integrity and justice. I am precisely the one who always sticks up for Fallon. And you don't, you don't give a damn about them. You were never there for them, and now you only want to save your own position! You are just trying to talk your way out of your own bad behavior at the expense of someone with a disability. And to Fallon, I don’t know if this may ever reach you, and you read it, but I want you to know I love you and I love your son Rory very much, I am sorry how things developed and went. I hope you and Harriet are still friends. I am sorry if I were too persistent to you, or you experienced it that way, but it was never my intention. Please understand I have autism as well. As Barry Hearn would say, I am only just a human being too, and I also make mistakes and misjudge things sometimes. I promise you I did everything out of the deepest love and care for you and Rory. If I were you, I should just keep all the money, only please never be dishonest or tell lies anymore for Barry Hearn, or anyone else. I hope you have the best life, and I wish nothing more than the best for you. I have always loved the two of you. Farewell.Hiddo05-11-2026
- She is a professional. If darts is her income, she is a professional. Same as Adrian Lewis, Martin Adams. A tour card just means someone can play on the PDC tour. You could even make a case that Clayton wasn't a professional (until recently I believe) because he had employment elsewhere.BandB04-11-2026
- She's technically not a professional though as she doesn't hold a pro tour card.mr-pablo04-11-2026
- Such a shame that lakeside has been reduced to this. Fantastic venue,and previously a great tournament. Not any morerick6703-11-2026
- Seems to me that the top 16 players pick and choose whatever they want to play. Good,all the money will get spread out more. They get more money from exhibitions than tournaments so let them all withdrawrick6703-11-2026
- Play all legs and the winners split the pot. Luke gets the lot of he wins them all. If your occupation is darts player you can't enter, regardless of ability.BandB01-11-2026
- I'm quite a jaded person all things considered, but to be honest I found Beat Luke Littler to be pretty entertaining. It certainly wasn't seamless, which is to be expected given the lack of precedence, but I actually think the pacing was pretty good, the production was impressive, and there was a good sense of humour and levity to it. I think it was a very ambitious undertaking but one that, for the most part, paid off. I liked the system with the four pots and I think it added to the drama and intrigue. I enjoyed seeing the diverse range of entrants and learning about their backstories. I think the interactivity was pretty clever and well-integrated. The panel was a little incoherent at times; Lee Mack shone however, and his improvisational skills were appreciated during some more awkward interstitial moments. As far as the darts is concerned, it was a shame that the format didn't allow Littler to get into full flow. You obviously don't want him to steamroll everyone but you want to feel like you're getting the full Littler package rather than seeing him struggling to get out of first gear. I will say that his leg against Jayden Walker was very impressive, but it was mostly downhill from there. The attraction revolves around Littler being this untouchable, indomitable force, yet the format doesn't really allow him to fulfil that characterisation. As for Fallon Sherrock, she was mightily impressive and deserved the victory. It is a testament to her unshakeable character that she was able to bang in a 14-darter under such mind-bending pressure. Everything that has been said about the misleading marketing is valid, though they were clear about their eligibility criteria and were able to offload the responsibility somewhat by bringing the viewers into the decision-making process in real time. What is clear though, is that Fallon played the game according to the rules, and she should not be criticised for that, much less abused. I will admit though that it is a kick in the teeth for those true amateurs who committed time and money to the course, and I would also question those who think pub players would have no chance, given that some of Littler's winning legs were dispatched in 7 visits to the board! The great thing about darts is that it isn't so much that amateurs cannot replicate the feats of brilliance pulled off by professionals of the sport, than it is that they simply cannot replicate the consistency of their output, something that this format almost entirely removes from the equation. It should also be noted that, financially, Fallon certainly stands to benefit much less in relative terms from the paycheque than would your average pub thrower, as I'm sure she nets a fair income from the lucrative exhibition circuit alone. What I do hope is that she might use this as an opportunity to really build up a head of steam heading into the new season, as it seems long overdue that she come through Q-School and really take it to the pros on a week-in week-out basis, but whatever she chooses to do, she has certainly achieved enough already for one if not several lifetimes, so who am I to dictate terms? To conclude though, I will state once again that I found Beat Luke Littler to be a pretty enjoyable evening of entertainment. I do feel for the contestants who never actually had the chance to try their luck against the world #1, although I suppose it comes with the format, but all which inevitably raises the question: will Netflix be tempted to do it all again next year? It's hard to say. Whether it would be financially viable, I can't weigh in there. One point I have been making though, and which I touched on earlier, is that the entire concept relies on a public perception that Littler is more or less unbeatable, and that certainly hasn't been the case of late. If the execs had been trying to pitch the show in recent months while Littler has seemed vulnerable, rather than when he was mopping up almost every major title on the calendar, it would certainly be a tougher sell. We will have to see in about 6 months' time whether Littler can still reliably command perception as a near-unstoppable force in darts, and then we'll have a clearer idea about whether we should expect a second helping. Even as a one-off experiment though, and with all the controversy taken into account, I still don't think they disgraced themselves by any means, and that will probably be my lingering assessment of the event when all is said and done.Deduce635801-11-2026











